OP02 Guessing in Spanish

Expressing Probability or Conjecture in Spanish In this audio lesson, we are going to practice expressing probability and conjecture with the future, future perfect and conditional Tenses. Example Paragraph To demonstrate how we use the future and conditional tenses to express conjecture, I wrote a paragraph about a photo from National Geographic. The photo was […]

You do not have access to this content. Log in below, become a member or upgrade.

  • Isn’t the Haber de + infinitive only used in literary writing or very formal speaking? Isn’t it better to use Tener que + infinitive in these examples?

    • Hola Chris!

      I love this question because I had the same impression as well. I always saw “haber + de” used to express obligation in books like “El amor en los tiempo de cólera,” but did not recall hearing it spoken in conversational Spanish. Then, when my friend returned from living 3 years in México, I noticed that she would often use “haber + de” to express probability. For example, you’ll often hear people say: “Ha de ser.” = “It must be.” More examples can be found here: http://www.spanishdict.com/examples/ha%20de%20ser

      Here´s another example from Ángel´s interview with his grandmother, doña Tere Rivas about her diagnosis of diabetes (https://docmolly.com/di-diabetes-patient-interview-diagnosis-treatment/)

      A: ¿Cuánto tiempo después del diagnóstico de diabetes empezó a tomar insulina?
      TR: Hmmm… Ha de ser como unos quince años.

      Here, “Ha(n) de ser como unos quince años.” = It must have been about 15 years.

      We cover this in the premium lesson: https://docmolly.com/di01-diabetes-patient-interview-vocabulary-grammar-1/

      OJO: In the above example, doña Tere Rivas used the singular of haber, “ha de….,” but given the predicate of the sentence is plural (quince años), I think it would be more grammatically correct to use ¨han de ser quince años.” But grammar isn´t perfect in the wild. ? and we usually sound more natural and fluent when you don´t worry about using perfect grammar, as long as we know how to use common expressions in the right context.

      I hope this helps! Thanks so much for your question. Please reply if other questions arise!

  • Tienes toda la razón Molly. He oído otra maestra decir que estas expresiones sólo ocurren en literatura pero he oído pacientes usarlas justo como tú explicas aquí.

  • {"email":"Email address invalid","url":"Website address invalid","required":"Required field missing"}

    Do you enjoy our lessons? 

    Would you mind sharing a short testimonial?